TL/DR Summary ‐--‐------------- Being able to dumb-fire missiles causes two issues and therefore I suggest that it should be removed. If tracking/CMs isn't properly balanced that balancing that should be the solution, not dumb-fire. Issue 1: With dumb-fire, a "blue" ship can just approach another ship (even with weapons powered down if that is visible at one point) without locking/targeting the other ship, posing to be friendly, and then once at point blank, can instantly dumb-fire a missile at the target while still being considered friendly by the system, as long as the victim isn't targeted. This makes a legal defense impossible for the victim, and also makes it extremely difficult for AI to enable NPCs to detect and try to counter/evade those clearly hostile actions. This is especially problematic with Eclipses, as they are also hard to detect, faster then cargo ships (so they can't run) and able to one-shot those. But it is neither limited to Eclipses nor S9s. Issue 2: Dumb-firing enables players to shoot at targets they are not supposed to be shooting at, therefore circumventing the rock-paper-scissors principle. Ballistas shooting at Novas, Eclipses shooting at Ballistas. Issue 3: There have been reports (I haven't tested it myself) that it is possible to dumb-fire missiles into armistice zones and destroy ships. ------ Edit #3 ------ It seems that currently, we don't have the right for legal self defense as giving a CS is just liked to dying without consideration of who was hostile to whom first. So legal defense doesn't work, dumb-fired or not. IMHO this is a bug, hopefully fixed with the CS remap in 3.18. As soon as this happens, issue #1 arrises. Original Post -‐-------------------- The ability to dumb-fire torpedos should be removed, as this is highly exploitable. Yes, I know, we all love dumb-firing S9 torpedos at A2s that approach Jumptown, but even though, dumb-firing offers an exploit that will become a big issue with 3.18, cargo refactor and salvaging: Currently due to the fact that pirates can't steal cargo, piracy is reduced to extortion. Pirates threaten traders to blow them up with a torpedo if they don't get payed. However, if a trader does pay the pirate, he cannot give the pirate an crimestat, therefore the pirate Eclipse stays "blue". And even if a pirate gets CS because he shoots at a ship, the CS can be cleared pretty quick. The problem with "blue" pirates and dumb firing is that even if the trader has his turrets manned, they cannot defend against the pirate. Normally, as soon as a pirate tries to lock you with a torpedo, he immediately turns "red" and your allowed to try to shoot him down. Plus you can at least try to use CM against the torpedos. But if an "blue" Eclipse just closes in and flies 50m behind you, for an guaranteed dumb fire hit, there's nothing you can do. If you shoot it down, YOU will be the aggressor, get CS and therefore loose your cargo. You can't use CMs. And while you can try to fly evasive maneuvers, that way you won't be able to escape the pirate (becausebit slows you down) OR call for help in global chat (because controlls are locked if your in chat). So you only delay the inevitable destruction. And as soon as the cargo refactor and salvaging comes into play, enabling pirates to earn by stealing your cargo and stripping your hull, this will become a real issue. As there's no way to give bombers an aggro-status for just getting close to you, the only way I see to prevent that exploit is to remove the possibility for torpedos to be dumb-fired. Edit To clarify things: This is not about piracy or extortion per se. And also not about a Eclipse pulling of an surprise attack. Nor is it about the fact that traders can't hire escorts because one fighter pilot earns twice as much as a trader so we simply can't afford escorts. It is about the fact that if an Eclipse decides to attacks a Caterpillar just leaving an trading outpost, even if the Cat has its turrets manned (which again, we usually can't afford) and no matter how good the pilot and the gunners are, the trader will loose its cargo: - Evasive maneuvers are nearly impossible with a Cat in gravity. - CMs don't work if the Eclipse dumb-fires. - Because the Eclipse isn't locking the Cat, it isnt considered aggor. Therfore it stays "blue" and the Cat isn't legally allowed to shoot back. Not while the Eclipse approaches, not even if the Eclipse fires. Not if it misses and shoots the next torpedo. The Cat will only legally be allowed to shoot back, after it is hit. Which is pointless because the S9 one-shots the Cat. - If the Cat still fires on the Eclipse, it will be considered as aggressor and get CS. - If the Cats turrets fire at the torpedo, chances are high that they will also hit the Eclipse, again resulting in CS. - To survive and keep the cargo, the Cat must -- Notice the attacking Eclipse -- Either manage to shoot down three torpedos without hitting the Eclipse -- Or destroy the torpedos and/or Eclipse while getting a CS AND manage to get to GrimHex to store his ship --- Without a bounty hunter killing him --- Without someone at GrimHex destroying him before he lands, which seems easy if your a regular at GrimHex, but for first time visitors with a Caterpillar, it will be challenging. Because, if the trader gets killed, even on foot, the Cat will be stored at Klesher and can only be recovered by claiming and therefore the cargo will be lost. Instead deactivating dumb-firing, another option would be to drastically increase the prices for missiles. Why does a S1 missile cost 80 UEC, but a t-shirt costs 800 UEC. A S9 torpedo that can one-shot a 30m ship shouldn't just cost 3.5k, but rather 100k. This of course would require that when you claim a ship, it comes without missiles. Of course, you should be able to restock them quickly, I don't want you to have to run around through the verse to buy them at selected shops. But you should have to pay for them. I mean, why should fighters get free missiles when claiming? Traders loose their cargo when claiming, miners loose their mining modules when claiming, (up to 180k for 3 moduels, so potentially 500k for a Mole), fighters not only keep the missiles they didn't use when claiming, but also get free replacements for the ones they used. Edit 2 The most brought up argument is that the main problem isn't dumb-firing, but the lacking criminal system. While this is certainly the case, and there are enough threads about it, this doesn't mean that dumb-firing isn't a problem as well and should be looked upon. So far, the most common argument brought up FOR dumb-firing is: It is in the game so it is an intended mechanic. While this is obvious, in my opinion, if we encounter that an intended mechanic creates severe issues, then stating that it is intended isn't a valid argument against the suggestion to remove it due to those issues. Some of the issues, and they are not (only) related to traders are: - It will be quite hard to manage the creation of CS and/or aggro just because someone is firing in the direction of a ship. Just imagine your a bounty hunter fighting a pirate, and a NPC patrol decides to engage the pirate as well, quickly moving into close pursuit of the pirate. No if you continue to fire at the pirate, suddenly you'll get a CS and/or aggro from the patrol because although you were firing at the pirate and didn't hit the patrol, you fired in the direction of the patrol. Therefore, being able to dumb-fire one-shot weapons will always create loopholes in regards to the aggro / crime system. - Missiles and torpedoes are really dangerous, large missiles can one-shot small ships, S9 can one-shot almost any ship. Which is okay per se, but if your able to fire those without any kind of warning within less then a second, no target is able to react. This creates lots of potential for griefing especially against beginners. A 100i or C8X has 3-4k hp plus 1.5k hp shields, so it can be one-shoted by any player dumb-firing a single S3 missile without the player even known what hit them. - Against PvE, dumb-firing S9s seems like an extreme exploit, as far as I read a skilled pilot has a nearly 100% chance to hit a NPC Hammerhead, so an Eclipse is able to consistently take out three Hammerheads in minutes. This is not balanced at all, if this would match the lore, then the UEE would only consist of carriers, light fighers, and stealth bombers. There would be no point in having a ship like a Hammerhead. Balance-wise., a Eclipse should have a fair chance of taking down a A2 or Hammerhead when using all three of it's torpedoes, maybe 50%. It shouldn't be able to take down 3 (!) Hammerheads 95% of the time, that's one person in a 3.5m ship consistently killing 21-27 persons in 38m ships. - Dumb-firing can currently still be exploited to blow up ships on landing pads, which clearly shouldn't be the case. Another issue that some of you mentioned is that tracking and CMs is currently unbalanced and therefore dumb-firing is currently the only way to use torpedoes effectively. While I do agree with the fact that the balance between target tracking and CMs currently is way of, with CMs being too powerful and easy to use, your argument shouldn't be "keep dumb-firing" (which causes the above issues) but instead "fix tracking vs. CMs". Your argument FOR keeping dumb-fire is missing balance regarding tracking/CMs. But then another argument from some of you is that even though dumb-firing creates issues, especially for traders those issues mostly exist due to missing balancing regarding risk/reward of traders vs combat pilots as well as the criminal system. So when missing balance is hurting you, you need to keep mechanics that ease your pain although they create a lot of issues for other players, but if those players complain about missing balance, they are just supposed to wait for years for things to be balanced?